Devalok
How a tradition frames it · 2 tellings · Pan-India

Baka Brahma's error and Sahampati's plea

Who is in it

The story, beat by beat

  1. Baka Brahma, in his high realm, believes his world is permanent and himself beyond death.
  2. The Buddha visits him and refutes him; a contest of vanishing follows, which Baka loses.
  3. The Buddha declares that Baka is wrapped in ignorance.
  4. After the awakening the Buddha hesitates to teach.
  5. Brahma Sahampati comes down and begs him to teach for the sake of those with little dust in their eyes.
  6. The Buddha agrees; Brahma has become a petitioner.

delusion supplication impermanence teaching

How it is told, place by place

Base telling · Encyclopedia

Pali suttas (Brahma-nimantanika, Ayacana)

Pan-India Buddhist Theravada Buddhist

Buddhism keeps the name Brahma but empties it of creation. In the Pali canon 'Brahma' is a rank of deities in the form realm, long-lived but not eternal and not the makers of anything. Two suttas show what this means. In the Brahma-nimantanika Sutta, Baka Brahma is sure his heaven will last forever and that he himself cannot die; the Buddha goes up to him, argues him down, wins a contest of disappearing, and pronounces him covered in unwisdom. In the Ayacana Sutta the roles are reversed in another way: after the awakening the Buddha is inclined to stay silent, and it is Brahma Sahampati, the senior of the great Brahmas, who descends to plead with him to teach. The creator of the Puranas has become first a deluded god and then a suppliant.

Brahmā (Buddhism) — Wikipedia; Mahabrahma — Wikipedia

Primary text (translation)

Vaishnava Buddha avatar

Pan-India Vaishnava

The Vishnu Purana and the Bhagavata absorb the Buddha the other way round, as a form Vishnu took to delude the enemies of the gods; Jayadeva's Gita Govinda later recast the motive as compassion for animals.

What is different here:

The Buddhist texts demote Brahma; the Vaishnava texts absorb the Buddha. Each tradition frames the other's central figure from inside its own scheme.

The Vishnu Purana: A System of Hindu Mythology and Tradition; Dashavatara — Wikipedia; Why is Buddha listed as an avatar of Vishnu?

Sources: Brahmā (Buddhism) — Wikipedia; Mahabrahma — Wikipedia; The Vishnu Purana: A System of Hindu Mythology and Tradition; Dashavatara — Wikipedia; Why is Buddha listed as an avatar of Vishnu?

More stories with the same people