Devalok
How a tradition frames it · 1 telling · Pan-India

Who made whom: the Bhagavata's creation frame

Who is in it

  • Brahma creator; father of Rudra
  • Rudra born from Brahma's anger
  • The four Kumaras refuse to procreate
  • Vishnu the source from whose navel Brahma is born (framing)
  • Parvati among the eleven Rudranis as Uma and Ambika

The story, beat by beat

  1. Brahma's four mind-born sons refuse his order to procreate.
  2. Brahma's anger rises and he tries to hold it back.
  3. From between his eyebrows a child coloured blue and red is born.
  4. The child cries and asks for a name and a place; Brahma names him Rudra for his crying.
  5. Brahma gives him eleven places in the body and the cosmos, eleven names and eleven consorts.
  6. Rudra's offspring threaten to devour the universe; Brahma tells him to stop creating and go to austerity.

creation supremacy emanation anger

How it is told, place by place

Base telling · Primary text (translation)

Bhagavata Purana 3.12

Pan-India Vaishnava

The Bhagavata's third canto tells how Rudra came to be. Brahma orders his first sons, the four Kumaras, to people the world; they refuse, preferring renunciation. His anger, which he tries to suppress, comes out from between his eyebrows as a child of mixed blue and red who cries and asks who he is and where he should live. Because he cried so, Brahma calls him Rudra, and gives him eleven seats — the heart, the senses, the breath, sky, wind, fire, water, earth, sun, moon and austerity — with eleven names (among them Manyu, Bhava, Kala, Vamadeva, Shiva) and eleven consorts including Uma and Ambika. When Rudra's own offspring begin to consume the universe, Brahma stops him and sends him to penance. Elsewhere the same text states its ranking outright: Shiva is joined to the three qualities of nature, Vishnu is beyond them (10.88), and the sages settle on Vishnu as the lord of goodness (10.89).

What is different here:

Base telling of this frame; Rudra is Brahma's son and subordinate, and Brahma in turn is Vishnu's, the reverse of the Shiva Purana's order.

Srimad-Bhagavatam (Bhaktivedanta Vedabase), cited by canto.chapter § 3.12; Srimad-Bhagavatam (Bhaktivedanta Vedabase), cited by canto.chapter § 10.88; Srimad-Bhagavatam (Bhaktivedanta Vedabase), cited by canto.chapter § 10.89

Sources: Srimad-Bhagavatam (Bhaktivedanta Vedabase), cited by canto.chapter

More stories with the same people